Midas Westhoek (AF Advisors): Transition investments under SFDR 2.0, Greenwashing 2.0?
This column was originally written in Dutch. This is an English translation.
By Midas Westhoek, Analyst, AF Advisors
A polluting company can be a justifiable transition investment. It is precisely in polluting sectors that funding the transition to cleaner production processes can make a real difference. But when can a transition be considered credible, and when is a polluting company simply being given a ‘green’ label?
In November 2025, the European Commission published its proposal for the revision of the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR 2.0). Under this proposal, the current classification categories set out in Articles 6, 8 and 9 will be replaced by product categories. The current classification categories were incorrectly used in the market as indicators of sustainability. For example, SFDR products under Articles 8 and 9 were labelled as so-called ‘light green’ and ‘dark green’ products, whilst the categorisation says little about the actual investments and their contribution to sustainability.
For this reason, three voluntary product categories are being introduced under SFDR 2.0: transition, ESG basic and sustainable. At least 70 per cent of the portfolio must support the chosen strategy, and specific mandatory exclusions apply to each category. The transition category is intended for investments in companies or projects that are not yet sustainable but are on a credible transition path. In its proposal, the European Commission excluded companies developing new fossil fuel projects from the transition category.
The Council opted for a different approach: these companies may still be eligible if they spend at least 20 per cent of their capital expenditure on taxonomy-compliant activities and have a clear, time-bound strategy to reduce their Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions. The European Parliament’s ECON Committee adopted the same rule on 10 September 2026, with an additional condition. Over a three-year period, a company must, on average, invest more in taxonomy-compliant activities than in new fossil fuel projects. Trilogue negotiations then began in October. An agreement is expected by the end of 2026 or early 2027.
Fossil fuels in the transition category
Is it desirable for products in the transition category to be allowed to invest in new fossil fuel projects? In February 2026, various organisations, including the WWF, called for companies developing new fossil fuel projects to be excluded from all three SFDR categories. Eurosif, the European umbrella organisation for sustainable investors, is also critical. Under the Council’s proposal, companies with plans to expand fossil fuel operations remain eligible, provided that 20 per cent of their capital expenditure is taxonomy-compliant and they have a plan for their own emissions.
Allowing companies with fossil fuel projects into the transition category is, in itself, justifiable. After all, that is precisely where the transition must take place. The risk lies in the benchmark. A fixed percentage of green investments says something about a proportion of capital expenditure, but little about the direction the company is taking. A company can invest in green energy whilst expanding its oil and gas production for years on end. Under the Council’s proposal, a limited level of green activity would then become a licence to present the entire company as a transition investment. The amendment by the ECON Committee largely addresses this, provided it is retained.
Room for fossil fuels, provided the course changes
We can only speak of a transition if green capital expenditure structurally exceeds fossil fuel expansion. Globally, almost twice as much money is expected to go towards clean energy as towards fossil fuels, but oil and gas companies account for less than 5 per cent of those investments in clean energy.
In addition, companies’ total emissions must also be taken into account. For fossil fuel producers, an estimated 80% to 95% of emissions stem from the use of their products (Scope 3 under the SFDR). A reduction strategy that covers only a company’s own emissions (Scopes 1 and 2) may therefore provide a limited picture. It is striking that the European Parliament’s proposal pays no attention to this.
Finally, a credible transition plan is needed to substantiate a company’s transition commitments, with science-based targets and interim milestones. This is currently also included in the proposals. Companies must have a time-bound and measurable strategy to reduce their Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions, which must also be compatible with limiting global warming in accordance with the Paris Agreement.
The transition category is not intended to be the strictest sustainability category, but rather to finance actual emissions reductions, including for companies that still have a long way to go in becoming more sustainable. Moreover, overly strict requirements could discourage investors from investing in the European capital market, which is precisely what SFDR 2.0 is seeking to prevent by simplifying the rules and reducing the administrative burden.
The outcome of the negotiations over the coming months will clarify the extent to which new fossil fuel projects may form part of transition investments. Fossil fuel projects can certainly form part of the transition category, provided they are underpinned by a credible transition plan. A transition category must, in any case, include at least one guarantee: namely, that fossil fuels will be phased out in the long term. Otherwise, greenwashing under SFDR 2.0 will simply be given a new name: transition.